Mr Fontenoy lost some of his primness. Everyone was staring eagerly at my lord. “Where you hid it, sir?”

“Where I hid it,” repeated my lord. “Now I have overheard you to say, Mr Fontenoy, that young Robert Tremaine was a romantic youth. It is very true! Years have not dulled the edge of my romantic fervour.” He laid down his snuff-box on the table before him, and his strangely compelling eyes swept the room. “They have only sharpened a brain that was always acute, gentlemen. You cannot fail to have observed a forethought in me that excites the admiration. I had it even as a boy.” He smiled benignantly. “Such a contingency as the present one I dimly expected, even in those far-off days. I saw that the day might come when I might desire to prove my identity. The romantic boy, Mr Fontenoy, hid a picture of himself in this very room, to serve as a proof if ever he should need one.”

“In this room!” ejaculated my Lord Clevedale, looking round.

“Certainly,” said my lord. “That is why I chose this room today.” He rose. “Tell me, cousin, are you a great reader?”

“No, I am not,” said Rensley curtly.

“Nor was my brother,” said his lordship. “I thought of that at the time. My father was much addicted to the works of Shakespeare but I believe he had no Latin.”

“What’s all this to do with it?” Rensley demanded uneasily.

My lord’s glance travelled to the top shelf of the books that lined the room. “Do you ever chance to take down the works of the poet Horace, cousin?”

“No, I do not, and I don’t see — ”

“Nor did my brother, I am convinced,” said my lord. “I thought it was safe — wonderfully safe, and wonderfully neat. I admire my own astuteness.” He met the puzzled eyes of my Lord Clevedale. “A great pity to have no knowledge of the humanities,” he said. “It is an estimable advantage. Had you been familiar with the Odes of Horace, cousin — but you are not. But take them down now: it is never too late to begin. Over in that corner, on the top shelf you will find the first volume, elegantly bound in tooled leather, the covers clasped by wrought hasps.”

“Pray, sir, what’s your meaning?” Mr Brent asked.

“Why, is it not plain?” said my lord. “I ask my cousin to pull the steps to that corner, and to take down the Odes of Horace. Let him open the clasps, and turn to the Fifth Ode.”

“You speak in riddles, sir.”

“But the riddle will very soon be answered, sir, if my cousin will do as I say. The first volume and the Fifth Ode. It will be most enlightening.”

Rensley went impatiently to the shelves. “Mountebank! What am I to find there?”

“The missing sketch, my dear Rensley, of course.”

“What!” Mr Clapperly looked up. “You put it there, sir?”

“I don’t believe it!” Rensley said, and went quickly up the ladder. He found the book, and pulled it out. A moment he fumbled with the clasps. The leaves parted naturally at the Fifth Ode. Mr Rensley stood staring down at the book.

Every head was turned his way. “Is it there?” demanded Mr Clapperly.

“You were told of this!” Rensley burst out, and flung the book violently to the ground. A drawing fluttered across the room, and was pounced on by Mr Fontenoy.

Instantly everyone save my lord went to peep over Mr Fontenoy’s shoulder. “It is certainly Robert Tremaine,” Mr Fontenoy said. He looked from it to my lord. “And there is — a likeness.”

“Why, damme, sir, the eyes and nose are exact!” cried Clevedale.

Mrs Staines ventured to speak. “’Deed, sir, but you have a look of Master Robert.”

“My good Maggie, you ought to know that I am Master Robert,” said his lordship. “I perfectly remember you.”

She stared. “You do know my name, sir. But your lordship will pardon me — it is so long ago, and you’ve changed, my lord.”

“So it would appear,” said his lordship. “I said I should satisfy you, gentlemen.”

“Pardon, sir,” Mr Brent interposed. “It seems a proof certainly. But we must not forget that you might have been told of this.”

“How?” inquired my lord. “No one but myself knew of it.”

“I am assuming, sir, for the moment, that you are not Tremaine.”

“An impertinence,” said my lord. “But I suppose I must forgive it. Pray continue. The legal mind is very wonderful.”

“And if — I only say if, sir — you are not Tremaine, you might have heard this from the man himself.”

My lord looked at him in blank astonishment. It was Clevedale who spoke. “Lord, what in the plague’s name would Tremaine tell such a secret for?”

“It is a possibility, my lord: I do not say a probability.”

“This is all quite ridiculous,” said my Lord Barham. “Moreover I am becoming weary of it. I bring you papers, and you say I stole them. I show you where I hid my own portrait, years ago, and you say I was told of it. I show you a ring, and you say I stole that. What a pity it is I have no birthmarks! Or would you say that I had stolen them as well? It is a very good thing that I brought my friend Mr Fontenoy. And here is Mr Clapperly as well may remember a little about me.”

“Vividly, sir.” Mr Clapperly inclined his head.

“Then I am sure you will remember the circumstances of my departure, all those years ago?”

“I do, sir.”

“Then I beg you will correct me if I should err in my tale. It is quite short.” He offered snuff to Clevedale. “My own mixture, Clevedale. You will like it. Well, gentlemen, you know that I was never at one with my father: he could not appreciate the genius that was in me. I disliked my brother only less than he disliked me. He hated me, I believe, but he would not have chosen to set you in my shoes, cousin, in spite of it. He was, after all, a Tremaine. I was no doubt a wild youth. I can remember incidents here and there — but no matter. I overspent my allowance with amazing regularity. I shall be careful to put no limits to my son’s income. Then I committed the indiscretion of falling in love with a lady called Maria Banstead. She was the daughter of a farmer.”

“Near Barham,” nodded Mr Clapperly.

My lord looked ironically across at him. “Your memory fails you, sir. Not in the least near Barham. She lived at Culverly, on the estate of my aunt Johanna’s husband. I was, I admit, young, and possibly hot-headed. But I have never regretted my marriage. An incomparable creature! I led her a sad dance I fear me. I eloped with her secretly, and went to France, just as soon as I heard that I had been thrown off by my indignant family. That is my story, gentlemen. Is it true?”

It was admitted to be true. My lord indicated the clerk with a wave of his hand. “Tell your clerk, Brent, to call my man in. He is in the hall.”

“Certainly, my lord. Go, Fawley.” It was the first time he had addressed my lord by his title and Rensley flushed as he heard him.

The clerk went out, and a moment later John stood in the doorway.

Everyone looked towards him, since it seemed he had been called for some special purpose. But my lord’s eyes were on Mrs Staines’ face. “He does not change much with the passing of time, I believe,” he said.

Mrs Staines was staring. The colour left her face, and she put up a hand to her ample bosom. “Johnny!” she faltered. “Oh, dearie, dearie, am I dreaming?”

Burton was incredulous. “It’s never our John!” he gasped. “Bless my soul, but it is really yourself, John?”

“Ay, it’s me,” John said grimly and sustained the shock of having his sister cast herself on his chest. “Well, Maggie, how do you, eh? Remember where you are, lass!”

Mrs Staines was quite oblivious of her surroundings. “Oh, Johnny, to think of you come back to us after all these years! Snakes, and I scarcely knew you, dearie, you’ve grown so grey! Sam, do you know your brother?”

Mr Samuel Burton gripped Mr John Burton’s hand. “Well, John!” was all he could find to say.

“Did you ever learn to master the bay mare?” John asked grinning.

It appeared to be an old jest. Samuel shook with laughter. “Lordy, John, to think you’d remember that! Ay, I was naught but a stripling then, and the mare the tricksiest piece — well, to think you’d remember!”

Surprise had held the others spellbound, but Mr Brent recovered himself. “Mrs Staines, do you recognise this man?”

“Oh, the legal mind!” murmured my lord.

“Why, of course I do, sir! It’s our John, who went off years ago soon after Master Robert.” She turned again to her brother. “And you’ve been with him all the time! Eh, and we never thought of it! But you was always saying you’d be off to Americky to try your fortune, Johnny, and we made sure you’d gone there.”

Mr Brent put a question no one thought needful. “Is this gentleman Viscount Barham?” he said.

John looked scornful. “Ay, of course he is,” he answered. “Is there ever another would have that nose but a Tremaine?”

“You have been with him all these years?”

“I have, sir, and a pretty dance he’s led me.” John smiled grimly at my lord. “Many’s the time I’ve told his lordship I’d be off home again. But we Burtons have always served Tremaine.”

There was a long silence. Mr Brent was slowly putting his papers together; Mr Clapperly smiled knowingly at his son; Rensley stood staring at the floor.

“Cousin,” said my lord. “I trust you are at last satisfied.”

“There is no more to be said, my lord,” said old Mr Clapperly.

My lord picked up his hat. “In that case I will take my leave of you. I should like my house at the end of a week, if you please. Brent, you will make the arrangements necessary, and put my terms before Mr Rensley. I hope he will not find me ungenerous. Clevedale, your arm!”