‘Do you have to do this?’ I demanded of my brother, young and malleable no longer, when I abandoned children and domestic life and rode hot foot to abrade him at Westminster.

‘Yes.’

‘John forsook his brother to support you.’

‘I’ll not dispute it, but it’s time to make an example of those who turned a blind eye to Richard’s misuse of power. Which means Exeter’s involvement puts him at the top of my list.’

I knew he meant the death of our uncle of Gloucester.

‘An example?’ As so often in those days my blood trickled icily.

‘Don’t worry. I won’t kill him.’

‘Well that’s a relief to know!’

‘All I mean to do is show my magnates that loyalty to me would be their best policy.’

It all left a bitter, lingering, taste in the mouth and John was quick to spit it out.

‘What more does he want?’ John snarled as, ultimately released without physical harm, he rode fast to Dartington—as far from London as he could get, he growled—where he stood in the middle of our new courtyard and dragged in a breath of free air. ‘I stood there with the rest of the sycophantic minions, through the whole of his damnably long-winded coronation. I took the oath. I perjured myself, after taking the damned self-same oath to Richard. I try not to think about my brother, still locked away in God knows what conditions in Pontefract. I have proved myself the perfect, loyal subject. Does that warrant my imprisonment?’

‘Henry thought it did. Are you going to come in or will you continue to shout your ills to the whole world?’

He had not yet moved past the new door lintel.

‘Ha!’ John’s glance was speculative, his mood still sour. ‘And what about you, my dearest wife? Were you worried for my safety?’

‘Yes. Henry promised he would not kill you.’

‘You went to see him to plead my cause?’

‘No, of course I didn’t. I left you to Henry’s tender mercies! Why would a wife plead her husband’s case?’ Tucking my hand in his arm, taking his gloves and hood to cast on a chest beside the door and setting myself to unpick the edges of John’s understandable disgruntlement, I drew him into one of the new rooms, where he would find warmth and wine and comfort. He looked sharply worn with weariness and irritation. ‘Be thankful he didn’t lock you in a dungeon in the Tower and forget about you.’

‘I’m thankful for nothing,’ he replied, although he had the grace to smile a little, a wash of colour on his cheekbones, as he allowed me to lead him in. ‘Your brother has taken the shears to my titles and estates fast enough. Did he learn that little trick from Richard? Your son will not be Duke of Exeter, lady. I’ll be lucky to hold onto Huntingdon for him. And what income we’ll have … your brother has confiscated the Duchy of Cornwall.’

‘I’ll speak to Henry,’ I offered, without much hope.

‘And beg for me again? You will not!’

‘Then I will not.’

After all we had salvaged, I could see our relationship falling into pieces again in front of me. Yesterday I had been awash with fearful desolation, not knowing when I would see John again. Today I was full to the brim with relief that John was free and returned to my governance, yet attacked with a whole new set of anxieties. He had not even kissed me in greeting. Not even touched me, although he had not resisted when I took the initiative. So although it was in my mind to set off for London, to rage against Henry once more, I pushed John to sit and poured him wine, shooing a curious Elizabeth from the room.

‘I don’t think that Henry will punish you more.’

John refused the wine. ‘How would you know what is in his head?’

‘I hope I do. I always did. He’s afraid that there will be a rising against him unless he shows a firm hand. So those who were close to Richard have to be held up as an example of what happens to a man who makes the wrong choice.’

‘Do you support him in this?’ His regard was not amenable. ‘I should have expected it.’

Looking down at where he slouched in his chair, all I could do was sigh.

‘All I’m saying is that Henry fears that if he does not watch his back …’

‘He has a right to fear it.’

Such a small comment, so seemingly inconsequential, spoken without heat. But uttered by a man grey-faced and eyes red-rimmed from long days of travel, it smote at my understanding. I stared at him. He looked back at me, eyes bleak and cold.

‘John! You wouldn’t.’

‘Wouldn’t what?’

‘I don’t know! Take up arms against Henry. Engage in a conspiracy …’

‘Why wouldn’t I? What have I to lose?’

‘Your head, for one.’

‘Would you care?’

Never had I known him so blighting, his words so unsparing of my sympathies. Not even in the days before Henry’s coronation. And as I took in the lines that marked his mouth and brow, I faced a sudden insight of impending disaster. I was once more tossed back into the morass of fear.

‘How can you say that?’ My tone as bleak as his. ‘You know I love you. I have always loved you and always will.’

Still his trenchant gaze held mine. ‘When Richard was arrested, the crown stripped from him, you rejoiced.’

‘I rejoiced that he no longer had the power to cause harm. Because he had hounded my brother and father, robbing Henry of what was rightfully his in the Lancaster inheritance. He had been instrumental in the murder of my uncle Gloucester. Yes, I rejoiced.’

‘When Richard was incarcerated in Pontefract, you were quick enough to sing your brother’s praises.’

‘Henry deserved it.’

‘When Henry was crowned you glowed with satisfaction.’ The accusations came thick and fast, his voice gaining power. So did mine.

‘Why should I not? Henry had every right.’

I felt as if I were on trial, but I would not retreat. I had done all those things, rejoicing that a mishandling of justice had been put right, even when I knew the hurt that John must feel.

‘When Henry has Richard done to death by some foul means, as I’ve no doubt he will at some opportune moment, will you celebrate then?’

Which effectively silenced me. Not just his words but the vicious emotion that had come to inhabit our new home as accusation followed counter accusation.

‘No. No, John. He would not. Nor would I rejoice.’

But I was not so sure. John was half-right in his charges against me, and it stung.

John sighed, some of the anger dissipating, to be replaced by what I could only think of as despair. ‘I think he might very well. As do you, if you’ll be honest with yourself. If he’s feeling vulnerable, he’ll rid himself of any rival. And that means Richard, with or without the crown.’ And then the despair thickened, his face becoming raw with emotion. ‘He is my brother, Elizabeth. You have faith in yours, God help you. How can I not feel it a mortal sin to betray mine? I betrayed Richard because I could not tolerate his lack of judgement, his poor government. It had become impossible to support a man who showed such cowardice in his flight from battle. I made the choice, but it tears at my heart, Elizabeth. Can you understand that?’

‘Yes. Yes, I do. But I can’t mediate between the pair of you for ever.’ I had a sudden vision of myself, old and grey, still trying to keep the peace between two recalcitrant men whose grey hair should have brought them wisdom, and hadn’t. ‘Don’t you see? It destroys me too.’ And in a final plea: ‘I cannot bear that we are once again cast into this cauldron of distrust.’

‘Of course I see.’ And at last he raised his hands in a gesture of supplication. ‘Perhaps it would be best if you take no notice of the diatribe of the past ten minutes. I am weary.’

I knelt at his feet.

‘I have been afraid for you.’

‘I know. I don’t doubt you, Elizabeth. I never will.’

But sometimes I doubted myself, my own capacity to love this difficult man, and yet I could not imagine my life without him. A familiar emotion stirred within my breast, heating my blood.

‘You haven’t kissed me yet.’

‘Then I must remedy so great an omission.’

He pulled me forward to kiss me, with all the old possession, yet even in the heat of his kiss, I sensed that his thoughts were elsewhere.

‘Are we at one?’ I asked, when I could.

‘I think so.’ A remnant of his grin. ‘As your husband should I not be able to command your fidelity?’

‘You do. Would I betray you?’

‘No. Not willingly. Not knowingly.’

We sat in silence for some time, hands clasped, as the sun moved round and filled the room with a blessing that unlocked all the tensions. Until I looked up and saw the cause of his stillness.

‘You are sleeping,’ I murmured. The carved leaves in the wood behind his head might not be the most comfortable, but his eyes were closed, his breathing even, the lines of strain fading.

‘Forgive me,’ he stirred. ‘Hertford was damned cold. I think Henry hoped to freeze me into submission.’

‘I thought you were intending to be submissive.’

‘So I am.’

But I did not believe him as we stood, his arms banding fast around me.

‘What do we do for the Christmas festivities?’ I asked.

John groaned against my throat where his lips were pressing a row of increasingly urgent kisses.

‘Henry and the children will be at Windsor,’ I continued. ‘Do we join them? It will look too particular if we don’t. I think we should go.’

‘What else?’ It was not quite a sneer. ‘We’ll celebrate and put on a good face between the dancing and the tournament. Perhaps someone will have the good fortune to run our sanctimonious King through his gut with a lance.’

I did not like the image but I kept the moment light. ‘But not you.’

‘No. Not me. Now come and reintroduce me to my newest son.’