They walked silently the first few blocks, serenaded by the crash of the surf in the distance and the chorus of tree frogs in the canopy of live oaks above them. Hank asked questions about the town and its history until they’d arrived at Annabeth’s front door. She stood there awkwardly, but Hank made no move to touch her as he had earlier that day in her shop.

“Annabeth Connelly, please have dinner with me.” He stood beneath her porch light, a moth dive-bombing his head, looking as though the fate of the world hinged on her answer. How could a woman say no to a request like that?

“Okay.”

“Are you free Saturday night?”

Lord, did this man think she actually had a social life beyond her book club and her church group? She had to admit to feeling a bit flattered. She couldn’t find the words, so she just nodded.

“Great. How about if I just pick you up from the shop?”

She nodded again.

Hank stepped away from her porch, ushering her inside, but Annabeth just stood there like a fool.

“I can’t leave until I know you’re safely inside, Annabeth.”

Right! Embarrassed, she quickly flew into the house, bolting the door behind her. As she leaned against it, she listened to Hank’s retreating footsteps down the gravel drive.

And that was how she found herself on the ferry headed for a private dinner for two.

“I have no desire to parasail,” she answered Hank. “I leave that to Will and his friends.”

He bristled beside her. “Will has a pretty extensive contract that prohibits him from parasailing for the time being, so please don’t tell me if he does.” He set the picnic basket down on the bench and leaned up against the railing.

Annabeth joined him, watching as the ferrymen untied the boat’s moorings. “Will takes his job very seriously; I doubt he’s been parasailing in ten years.”

“Annabeth, can we maybe forget that you’re Will’s mother and I’m his boss tonight? I’d prefer we just be Annabeth and Hank, two people who want to enjoy a nice dinner and get to know one another.”

The ferry pulled away from the dock, and Annabeth didn’t know whether it was the bobbing of the boat or the potent effect of the man beside her, but she needed to sit.

“Okay.” She settled on the bench, and Hank sat down beside her. “If we’re getting to know each other, tell me about your wife. Elizabeth.”

Hank paused in pulling a bottled water out of the picnic basket. “Ex-wife. Elizabeth and I haven’t been married for over ten years.”

She shook her head when he offered the bottle. “What ended the marriage?”

“Wow, now I see where Will gets it. You pull no punches.” He took a swallow of water before capping the bottle and returning it to the basket. “The usual, I guess. I wasn’t a very attentive husband, and Elizabeth needed more than I was giving her. So she found it somewhere else.”

Annabeth wasn’t sure what shocked her more, that Hank would admit to being a neglectful husband or that his wife would cheat on him.

“She cheated on you?”

Hank smiled at her incredulousness. “I wasn’t exactly faithful to her, either.”

It suddenly felt like a balloon had deflated inside Annabeth. Despite her attempts not to throw her heart into this relationship, she realized that his admission stung. A lot. She pulled her legs up on the bench, resting her chin on her knees to try to keep the disappointment from seeping into her heart.

Hank sighed. “Not in the way you’re thinking. It wasn’t another woman. Football was my mistress.” The boat picked up speed and he had to sit closer to her in order to be heard. “I played football at West Point. I knew I wouldn’t go pro—I wasn’t good enough—but that didn’t keep me from dreaming of being involved in the game somehow. After I finished my tour in the Army, we’d been married a year and Elizabeth was pregnant with Sophie; the plan was for me to go to Wharton and get my MBA. I’d join the family firm and Elizabeth and I would take up residence in Philadelphia society.”

The whipping wind kept blowing a strand of hair in Annabeth’s face, and she shoved it aside as she listened to Hank’s tale.

“A friend of mine who worked with the Philadelphia Eagles called one day and said they were looking for a scout, someone to travel to college campuses and assess the football talent. The job barely paid anything, but both Elizabeth and I are trust fund babies.” He shrugged unapologetically. “I didn’t even tell her. Or my dad. I just took the job because I desperately wanted to do something in the NFL.”

Hank hung his hands between his knees as the boat jumped across the choppy waters. “The job required a lot of travel. A lot, but I wanted to do it well, so I didn’t complain. I nearly missed Sophie’s birth and, well, it goes without saying that I missed pretty much all of her firsts.”

He glanced out over the ocean, and Annabeth glimpsed the pain in his eyes.

“If she really loved you,” she said, “she would have persevered through those years while you pursued a dream.”

“If I really loved her, I would have found a way to meld my dream and my marriage better. I would have made it work.”

His admission stirred something inside Annabeth: empathy, certainly. But jealousy, too. She wanted a man to love her enough to make something, anything, work.

“But thank you, Annabeth. It would have been nice to have someone on my side back then.”

“Your family sided with Elizabeth?” She didn’t know why that thought hurt her so much, but it did. Hank was a good man. To know that his family turned their backs on him when he needed it pained her greatly.

“They sided with Sophie. Elizabeth is her mother. She and Kevin were discreet in their affair, so nobody but me was the wiser.”

“But your family should know she cheated on you!”

“No, Annabeth, they shouldn’t. That would only hurt Sophie. She lives with Kevin and Elizabeth and two younger brothers who’d slay dragons for her. Despite her teenage drama, she has a comfortable, stable family life. There’s no reason to upset it with something that’s in the past.”

The boat slowed as it arrived at the island’s harbor, giving Annabeth time to study the man seated next to her. He was not what she’d first thought. She’d assumed he’d become less appealing the more she was exposed to him and the more he found out about her. Instead, she discovered that beneath his handsome exterior was a man who had a generous heart. Somehow, her heart beat a few ticks faster just knowing that.

She tilted her head, laying her cheek on her knees. “So football is your first love.”

“It was then.”

“And now?

His eyes bored into her. “I’m working on developing a different game plan.”

The boat bumped the edge of the dock, nearly knocking her from her perch. Hank stood, picking up the picnic basket, and reached down to help Annabeth to her feet. She slid her hand into his, the warm contact feeling right.

They disembarked and headed up the hill.

“You aren’t planning on us hiking one of the trails, are you?” She gestured to her sandals with the wedge heel. She’d dressed carefully today in a peach linen blouse and cream capri pants.

Hank leisurely looked her up and down, his face registering his approval. “No. Our chariot awaits us at the surf shack up there.”

True to his word, a golf cart with a piece of paper bearing Hank’s name taped to the seat was parked outside the shop. He loaded the basket into the back and helped Annabeth in before walking around to start it up. The cart sputtered up the bend through a line of tourists heading for the lighthouse.

“Hey, is that lighthouse actually open to the public?” he asked.

“It is,” she laughed.

Hank jockeyed the golf cart up to the small store at the base of the lighthouse. “I’ve never been in a lighthouse before. Let’s go up.” His childlike exuberance was hard to ignore.

“It’s one hundred and eight steps to the top; do you think you can handle it?’ she teased.

“Oh, Annabeth, now you’ve challenged my manhood and we have to go.”

He bought them each a ticket, and Annabeth was grateful for her thrice-weekly spin classes as they nearly sprinted to the observation deck. The windows were small and they had to crowd together to see out. The boats in Chances Inlet Harbor bobbed in their slips, the sunlight reflected off them winking back at the lighthouse.

Annabeth peered at her home. “The town looks so small from over here.”

“It is a small town,” Hank said from behind her, his breath fanning her ear. The heat from his body warmed her back. “Do you ever feel like it’s too small? Like you want to explore somewhere else?”

Exploring someplace else would be far out of her comfort zone. She knew who she was in Chances Inlet; she didn’t have to fake being someone she wasn’t. But there were times she wanted to see what else was out in the world. She just didn’t think she could face what was out there alone. Not yet, anyway.

“I don’t do well with new things and new experiences,” she whispered.

Hank braced his hands on either side of the wall beside her head. “Maybe you just need to quit trying new things solo.” His words caressed the back of her neck.

She turned her head slightly, her lips an inch from his. “Maybe.”

A group of chattering teens stormed up the stairs, and Hank led her back out to the golf cart. They drove across the island to the west side, where a row of spectacular beach houses dotted the dunes bordering the Atlantic. Hank pulled up to a driveway of a large cedar-shake house situated right on the ocean.