"You look strange. Did you drink too much of your friend's wine? There is a flush about your face. Carolan, are you all right?”

"I am quite all right. I am not tipsy either! Ah! Here come my pen and paper. Now hear me ask for water and a bandage. I can give orders now because I have a friend named William Henry ... and he has money...”

It was some time before Carolan joined them on the bed. She had written to Everard; she and Esther had bathed and bandaged Kitty's leg; Esther had knelt down by the bed and thanked her God for this newly acquired luxury. Carolan lay very still; she was cramped, and it was impossible to move without disturbing the others. Millie was snoring; Kitty was breathing deeply; Esther, Carolan believed, was awake.

"Esther!" she breathed.

"You do not sleep.”

Esther's voice came to her in the darkness.

"It is the unaccustomed comfort. The bed is so soft... I am so used to hard planks.”

"Why do you cry, Esther?”

"Because it is so wonderful. Because I have prayed for something like this to happen.”

There was a silence, then Esther said: "He is very kind, your friend.

He is a good man, though he tries so hard to pretend he is not.”

"He is a thief!" said Carolan.

"He is a rogue... Do not forget that. He was not brought to this place wrongfully.”

"But Carolan, you have said that no one should be brought to a place like this whatever their crime. You said it. Then he has been brought here wrongfully."

 "Hush!" said Carolan.

"You will wake the others." She tried to sleep, but she could not. She lay there, cramped. uneasy, thinking of Marcus.

It was stiflingly hot in the women's quarters. When Carolan had stood at the top of the ladder and peered down into the darkness below, she had felt sick with hopelessness and terror. The women's quarters consisted of double tiers of bunks roughly divided into berths; and sharing Carolan's was her mother, Esther, a crippled girl of twelve and a middle-aged woman. The little girl had cried intermittently ever since they had come aboard; she refused to talk to anyone, and would hide her face in her hands, peering through her fingers, if spoken to, suspicious and defiant. The woman had been drunk all the time the ship lay at anchor; gin had been smuggled in for her; now the ship had set sail and she no longer had her gin, she was either quarrelsome or over-friendly. She sang lewd songs for hours at a stretch; and in close confinement with this woman, Carolan knew that she, her mother and Esther must spend the next months. Millie they had not seen since leaving Newgate. Her sentence had been the same as Carolan's seven years transportation but she had been sent to another ship. Poor Millie! It was to be hoped she would not suffer too deeply. Carolan thought of her often, hating herself, for it seemed to her that never would she be able to forget that she had been the chief instrument in bringing trouble to these people.

But even in the depth of misery there is some comfort to be had. They were all together she, her mother and Esther and it might so easily have happened that they would be parted. She believed, though she was not altogether sure, that Marcus was aboard this ship. Marcus she had told him that never, never could she think of him as anyone but Marcus, to which he had replied characteristically: "What's in a name? As long as you continue to think of me, what matters the label?" Marcus had been sentenced to transportation for life, Kitty for fourteen years, and Esther, like herself, to seven.

She would clench her hands and think of the mockery of the trial, the weariness of the court, its automatic and careless sentences. It is so much easier to say "Guilty!" than "Not Guilty!" And who is to care, save a poor prisoner of no significance whatever?

Always there would stand out in her memory the ride to Portsmouth.

Chained, dirty not Carolan Haredon surely, this creature, whose red hair, once so sleek and shining, was matted and filthy! Carolan, who had danced in a green dress at her first ball, now a grotesque scarecrow, her thin body hung about with rags. The van had been open and crowds in the street had watched its progress. They laughed; they pointed; they jeered at the van's most miserable cargo.

She had prayed then she who had vowed never to pray again.

"Let me die. This I cannot endure." Then someone had thrown a rotten apple at her and she had stopped praying, for furious anger had surged up within her. She had seized the apple and flung it back into the crowd, which action had been greeted with roars of ribald laughter; and then rotten fruit, mud, dung came thick and fast.

"I'll never forget it, she thought; and indeed the very memory of it set her heart pounding with fury.

In Portsmouth jail with its Gentlemen's Side and its Common Side in fair imitation of its big sister, Newgate they had dined with Marcus.

His eyes had glittered with excitement because the last days of prison life had been lived through. There was the weary waiting before they set sail, there was the dreaded journey across the sea to the other side of the world, but the filthy Newgate days were over, and that in itself was a matter for rejoicing.

Marcus had said: "My darling, how it grieved me that you should travel down as you did! Believe me, I tried to move heaven and earth to get you with me in a closed carriage. There are some things that money cannot achieve please understand that that was one of them.”

She tried to tell him of that journey, but the words choked her, and she spoke only one sentence to sum the whole thing up: "I wished I was dead.”

"Carolan, my sweet," he said, 'never wish that. That is an admission that life has defeated you. Why long for death when you know not what it brings! Eternal sleep? Do you want it, Carolan? That sort of death is not for us, Carolan, and the only sort of life we know is the hard life and would such as we are want it soft? Would it not lose its zest?”

"Esther has beautiful ideas of death," she said. And they had both looked at her. There was an unearthly beauty about the girl; her spiritual strength shone in her eyes for her belief was invulnerable.

"But Esther, how can you be sure?" demanded Carolan, irritated.

"How can you be not sure," asked Esther, 'when you know?”

"You do not know!" said Carolan, impatient.

"Who has ever told you? Your father? Your mother? But what did they know?”

"They knew." said Esther.

"I could not bear not to believe.”

"It is comforting, doubtless," said Carolan. Marcus put his hands on her shoulders.

"But Carolan, do we want comfort? I do not think so: not unless we know it to be truth. We cannot accept things because they are comfortable. Why, Dammed, our forefathers doubtless thought it was comfortable enough living in their uncivilized way. It is the uncomfortable things which make the world progress.”

Esther shook her head.

"I wish I could make you see it as I do.”

"Ah, Esther!" said Marcus.

"We are neither of us saints, Carolan and II" "No," said Carolan, 'we are sinners ... angry sinners. We cannot accept cruelty because God decided that we should. No, we will fight against God; we will fight for ourselves!”

Marcus laughed. How his eyes glittered! She thought. He is already contemplating escape when he gets to Botany Bay. And she warmed towards him; they were much of a kind, he and she. Everard was of a kind with Esther. Everard was ever constant in her mind. Everard who had not come for her, who had accepted cruelty as God's will. Perhaps he had wanted to come; she imagined his mother's begging him not to ... and Everard's fighting with himself. Everard the parson. Everard the lover. She had always suspected the parson of being the stronger of the two. Perhaps that was why she had suffered so deeply in the van which had taken her to Portsmouth, for then she had known that Everard was not coming; that was why. in the open van on the Portsmouth Road, she had despaired.

And when she had thrown that rotten apple back into the crowd, she had been throwing it at Everard and Everard's mother. Had she been unshackled, she would have leapt from the van and fought them with her hands. She was not the sort to suffer in silence, to pine away and die; she was the sort to fight, to hurt herself, to hate... "I wish I were dead." she said again, remembering.

And then there had been the comfort of seeing Marcus in the Portsmouth jail. That jauntiness of him, that glitter in his eyes! Rogue, thief, philanderer that he was he was more her sort than gentle Everard.

One pain will subdue another. There was poor Mamma getting weaker and weaker, and thinking of Mamma it was possible to forget Everard a little.

The last weeks had changed Kitty beyond recognition. She was like a flower that has been cherished in a hot-house, and is thrown onto a dung heap. No flower could be expected to last long in that condition.

When they had come on board and had stayed on deck while farewells were said, Kitty had sat propped up against the rail unable to move. Her face was a greenish colour, her eyes bloodshot, her tongue thickly coated, and her lips twice their usual size. She was, Carolan knew, unaware of her situation, which was perhaps not a matter for regret in itself.

All about them were their ribald companions of the voyage, men, women, boys and girls; murderers and highwaymen, people who had stolen a loaf, of bread, river thieves, counterfeiters the innocent and the guilty.

Gin flowed freely. Old songs were sung.

Some sang of their joy to be rid of their country; some were sentimental in a maudlin way about leaving it Men and women embraced openly; young boys and young women, mere children, followed their example. Conversation was as obscene as they knew how to make it. Some danced; some sang; some wept; some laughed. And Kitty sat there, propped up, seeing nothing.