Carolan sprang to her feet with an effort, her fists clenched, anger, which now came so easily, rising within her.

"Please," said a voice that was neither strident nor cruel, but gentle and cultured.

"I... I would like to talk to you." The girl sat down: there was something so disarming about her that Carolan's suspicions gave way to curiosity.

"What do you want?" she asked ungraciously.

"Only to talk to you. Is... she... your mother?”

"Yes.”

"Poor soul. She is of gentle birth, I see. This must have been horrible... horrible... for her!”

"Yes," said Carolan and moved closet to the girl.

"Have you no clothes?”

"No. They took them. I could not pay garnish. Besides...”

"Are you not cold?”

"At first I was very cold; you do not feel it so much after a while.”

"How long have you been here?”

"I do not know for certain. As far as I can calculate about a month.”

Carolan shivered.

"How do you endure it?”

 "God helps me," said the girl.

"He gives me wonderful comfort.”

"Comfort?" said Carolan.

"Spiritual comfort.”

Carolan laughed bitterly.

"I will give you more than spiritual comfort. I with give you my petticoat.”

The girl did not answer and Carolan moved closet to her.

"Did you heat me say I would give you my petticoat?”

The girl was weeping softly.

Carolan, tactless, impulsive, and ready to suspect all, said harshly: "Now what does this mean? You are happy when you are given comfort which is cold, hunger and other frightful things I have yet to discover, but the offer of a petticoat sets you weeping!”

"Forgive me!" whispered the girl.

"It is so long since anyone has been kind.”

Now Carolan was ashamed, for she saw that the girl was very frail. She stood up, slipped off her tattered dress and the petticoat beneath.

"There!" she said in an outburst of generosity.

"You have the dress; the petticoat will cover me.”

"I cannot take either." said the girl.

"You are a fool; you will freeze to death!”

"Yes," said the girl slowly, 'in the winter, if I am still here, I shall freeze to death. I shall not be the first.”

"You may not be here," said Carolan, her spirits rising through contact with someone more wretched than herself, new strength coming to her at the sight of another's weakness. There is no point in freezing to death before winter!" The girl put out eager fingers and stroked the petticoat.

"If I had it." she said, 'they would have if off me tomorrow. I saw the way you stood up to them; you were magnificent; I cannot tell you how I admired you. You got strength from God.”

"No," said Carolan, 'from a more reliable ally anger!" The girl caught her breath, and folded her arms across her bare breasts. She looked, thought Carolan, like a saint, and felt humbled and feigned anger to hide her shame.

"Now do not be so foolish," she said.

"Put on this petticoat at once. And if they try to take it from you tomorrow, they will have me to deal with.”

The girl raised her eyes to the oil lamp, and Carolan saw that she was beautiful.

"I prayed this day for a miracle," she said.

"I believe it.has come.”

"Rubbish!" said Carolan.

"And if you think that my coming with my mother and our poor serving-maid to this hell is a miracle, I can tell you we do not look on it as such. There, are you warmer?”

The girl looked up at her shyly, for Carolan was several inches taller.

"How kind you are!" she said.

"It is wicked of me to be glad you have come to this dreadful place, but I cannot help it.”

Carolan was happier then than she had been since that nightmare moment when she had stood on the threshold of the shop parlour and seen her father lying on the floor.

There is not much warmth in that petticoat, I fear," said Carolan.

"There is a good deal of warmth in it. And will you really let me keep it? And will you stop them from taking it from me?”

"I will!" said Carolan.

"Sit down beside me.”

 "I... I am unfit to sit too close.”

"Come close." commanded Carolan.

"Is there nothing we can do for your mother?”

"What can we do? I would bathe the blood from her face, but there is no water. I would like a little spirit to revive her, but where can I get it?”

"You cannot get these things if you have no money. Have you friends ... outside?”

Carolan said: "Certainly I have friends friends who will see that justice is done. But they are far away in the country. I must get a message to them.”

"How will you get a message to them without money?”

Carolan said in a frustrated tone: "Do not let us speak of my distressing affairs! Tell me of yours; what is your name?”

"Esther March. What is yours?”

"Carolan Haredon.”

"May I call you Carolan?”

"Of course!”

"Why are you here, Carolan?”

"On a false charge," burst out Carolan.

"I would not have believed there was such wickedness in the world!”

Esther touched Carolan's shoulders timidly, "Do not despair.”

Despair!" cried Carolan angrily.

"How can one but despair of this wicked place; in the country it was so different ..." She stopped. Was it so different? She thought of Jim Bennett, the farm labourer who had stolen a rabbit from Squire Haredon's fields. What had happened to him? She had heard vague talk of fourteen years ... Transportation of course; there had seemed nothing unusual about that; she had not given the matter a thought.

There was a sob in her throat now.

"I have been blind," she said.

"Blind!" She cried out: "Do not talk of me! Later I will tell you; but now I would hear of you. What brought you here? You stole nothing! You did no crime!”

"It is good of you to believe that, and even before I have said a word.”

"I am no fool!" said Carolan, and laughed inwardly at herself, for was she not the biggest, the most easily duped of all fools who had ever led themselves and others to destruction!

"I would like to tell you of myself," said Esther.

"It is an ordinary enough little story, I fear. My father was a curate, and we were very, very poor. There were six of us. But he taught me, and when I was sixteen I was given a post as governess in the family of a squire... and the squire had a son." She looked down at her hands, and Carolan was aware of the deep shame that beset her.

"He ... made advances ... which I could not accept, and that made him very angry. I did not know what to do, and I sought the protection of his parents. They did not believe me ... and when the squire's lady lost a valuable ring she accused me ... and the ring was found in my room, and I was brought here. But I swear I knew nothing of the ring!”

"But did you not explain?”

The ring was found in my room.”

"She put it there that wicked mother of a wicked son! Oh, how I hate this world!”

"Whom the Lord loveth He chasreneth. We must bear our sufferings with fortitude. That is what my father used to say. They were sent us for a purpose. We must be meek, for it is the meek who inherit the earth.”

"That is a doctrine I will never accept. I will tell you something; I am going to marry a man who is a parson.”

"Oh!" Esther exclaimed with delight.

"I am glad ... Carolan.”

"But," said Carolan, 'there are matters on which we cannot agree. I do not think we should accept our sufferings and the sufferings of others.

Everard and I almost quarrelled about that. He said I was headstrong, illogical. He believes that people should be contented with their lot in life because that lot has fallen to them through God's will. I do not! I never will!”

"Godliness," said Esther, 'is humility!”

"Then I'll have none of it!" cried Carolan.

"When I think of what has happened to me ... and my poor darling Mamma ... and Millie there ... and what has happened to you, I want to set faggots in this place, and pour oil on them, and I want to see this evil place go up in smoke. And yes ... I would throw Jonathan Crew, who betrayed my father, into the flames ... and with him your wicked squire's son and his mother ...”

"Ah, Carolan, you must not say such things, for truly it is the will of God that we are here.”

"Since you are obviously a saint, you had better steer clear of me.” said Carolan.

"I love the fire in you. It warms me. And I am so cold, so lonely and so frightened! I am wicked too, for I have had more comfort from your presence than from my prayers. There! That shows how wicked I am, does it not? Are you crying too? We must not cry, Carolan. This is our cross, and we must bear it. You see, I who have been so wretched, Carolan have had my prayers answered. I have now a friend, someone who talks to me, listens to me, who doesn't laugh at me, who does not pinch me and kick me and scratch me, who gives me clothes to covet me.”

"Why did they take your clothes ... all your clothes?" demanded Carolan. The others have some rags to cover them.”

"When I came in," said Esther, 'they cried at me, as they do to all, "Garnish!" I had no garnish. I had nothing ... nothing but the clothes in which I stood. What could I do, therefore? They tore them from me as they did from your mother. But they left me my shift. And that night I knelt down and prayed, because my father has always said to me, "Never mind where you are, whatever you are doing, you must always kneel down and say your prayers." I always had; and I did. And as I prayed they crept closer to me. Carolan, I am so feeble; I have no godliness in me, though I try to be good like my father. I knelt over there; you see, near the sill there. Through my closed lids I was aware of the flickering light from the whale oil lamp, and, Carolan, I tried so hard to go on with my prayers and not notice them. But I was afraid; I was more afraid than I had ever been before in the whole of my life. I could feel them creeping up to me; I did not know what they would do to me. I could smell their mingled breaths very close to me, and it was horrible, horrible, Carolan. You who are so brave could have no idea. Closer, they came; they were all round me; then one of them laughed. It was terrible laughter, Carolan. I trembled; I stopped praying; I covered my face with my hands, for I knew that the most terrible moment I had ever known was upon me. There I knelt in my shift, saying under my breath, as my father had taught me, "Courage, O Lord; give me courage!" Then they started." She stopped, and covered her face with her hands; she began to sob.